How Should We Handle Salary Increases?
Rethinking Raises: How to Make Smart, Sustainable Pay Decisions
For many business owners and HR leaders, salary increases feel more like guesswork than strategy, especially when inflation, shifting labor markets, and rising employee expectations all collide.
Should you apply across-the-board raises? Prioritize performance? Adjust for inflation? And how do you balance fairness with financial discipline?
The answer isn’t a formula. It’s a mindset shift. A thoughtful, structured approach to raises can do more than manage costs. It can build trust, drive performance, and support retention.
Where Things Go Off Track
Two patterns show up often:
Ad hoc decisions when someone pushes for more money or threatens to leave.
Flat increases given to everyone, regardless of performance or market relevance.
These reactive approaches may feel quick and easy, but they often lead to internal pay inequities, disengagement, and missed opportunities to recognize top talent.
A More Strategic Approach
Organizations that handle raises well tend to blend three key considerations:
1. Performance – Rewarding employees who deliver strong results, not those who have just been there the longest.
2. Market movement – Staying aligned with evolving compensation benchmarks, especially for hot-skill jobs or underpaid positions.
3. Cost of living – Maintaining real income value in inflationary periods without overcommitting.
This blend allows flexibility while reinforcing fairness and transparency.
Why It Pays to Be Intentional
Without a structured approach, you risk:
— Losing top performers who feel under-rewarded
— Overpaying average performers just to keep them
— Creating resentment among employees when increases feel arbitrary
Even with tight salary budgets, purposeful decisions can make a difference. For example, one company used a 4% salary pool but allocated it in bands: top performers received 6%, solid contributors got 3%, and no increase for low-performers. This approach is not designed to be punitive. The objective is to improve morale by rewarding excellence.
Getting Started
Set a calendar. Define regular raise review periods to reduce uncertainty, inconsistency, and last-minute decisions.
Support your managers. Equip leaders with practical guidance for making and explaining raise decisions with confidence.
Be transparent enough. Employees don’t need a spreadsheet with every detail, but they do need to understand what matters.
Final Thought
Raises aren’t just a retention tool. They’re a reflection of how your company recognizes value. You don’t need a bigger budget to make raises work better, you need a well thought out plan.
If your current process feels inconsistent or unclear, it might be time for a fresh approach. Let’s talk.
How does your compensation stack up?
Participating in a compensation survey is a wise investment in your company’s future.
Learn more about the 2024 HR Consulting Industry Compensation Survey.