Should You Have a Bonus Plan?
When Incentives Help—and When They Hurt
Business leaders often ask, “Do we need a bonus plan?” But the more revealing question is: What are you trying to drive?
Incentives can be a powerful tool, if they’re used well. They can focus effort, reward progress, and reinforce priorities. But when poorly designed, they become noise: misunderstood by employees, misaligned with goals, and more frustrating than motivating
What the Right Plan Can Do
A bonus plan works best when it sends a straightforward message: “Here’s what we’re aiming for and here’s how you can share in the success.”
That message only lands when employees understand the plan, believe in the targets, and trust the process. Without those anchors, even generous payouts fall flat.
One client—a service firm with about 75 employees—had a profit-sharing program that had gone stale. Payouts were flat for years, and no one knew how the numbers were calculated. Once leadership refocused the plan on a few key outcomes their team could influence, engagement turned around almost immediately. It wasn’t the size of the bonus that changed, it was the improved focus and measurement.
When Incentives Work
Incentives tend to succeed when the link between effort and outcome is strong. That might be hitting safety targets, improving customer retention, or increasing production efficiency. In the right context, even modest rewards can create measurable shifts in behavior, because people understand why it matters.
When to Be Cautious
Bonus plans can backfire if they’re overly complicated, poorly communicated, or seen as a substitute for fair base pay. If employees don’t understand how success is measured or don’t trust the process, the plan becomes a distraction. Or worse, a source of resentment.
Incentives can’t fix a weak pay structure or inconsistent leadership. But they can amplify a strong culture, sharpen performance, and align teams around what counts.
If your current plan isn’t delivering—or if you’re considering one but unsure where to start—it may be time for us to have a conversation.
How does your compensation stack up?
Participating in a compensation survey is a wise investment in your company’s future.
Learn more about the 2024 HR Consulting Industry Compensation Survey.